Once I quickly switched from an iPhone to an Android telephone final week, I used to be bracing for a world of harm. I’ve owned solely Apple telephones ever since shopping for the first-generation iPhone in 2007. And, like many, I’ve purchased different Apple merchandise that pair properly, together with AirPods, an Apple Watch and an iPad.
That kind of loyalty is the premise of an antitrust case in opposition to Apple introduced by the Justice Division, which has accused the corporate of utilizing monopolistic management over the iPhone to hurt rivals and deter prospects from switching to different telephones. To check that concept, I made a decision to briefly break up with my iPhone.
I used to be initially stunned by how easy it was to shift my iPhone information to an Android smartphone made by Google. Simply by putting in an app on my iPhone that Google made to assist individuals swap, I used to be in a position to copy my contacts record, photograph album and calendar into my Google account. Then, presto — all that information appeared on the Android.
I used to be virtually executed. After I referred to as my service, Verizon, to switch my telephone quantity to the Android gadget, my mission was completed: I had turn out to be an Android convert.
At first, I used to be proud of my selection — I had upgraded to a flowery Google Pixel telephone. However by Day 6, I used to be prepared to modify again.
A bunch of annoyances added up. Despite the fact that I might nonetheless use most of my Apple merchandise, I began lacking my Apple Watch, which requires an iPhone to totally work. For software program, I used to be capable of finding Android options for all my favourite apps — apart from Notes. Whereas switching telephones wasn’t technically laborious, Apple’s hooks had been nonetheless in me.
How Apple retains prospects loyal to the iPhone — and whether or not its practices hurt competitors — is on the coronary heart of the authorities’s antitrust swimsuit in opposition to the Cupertino large.
Apple and the Justice Division declined to remark.
In its 88-page criticism, the division mentioned quite a lot of Apple merchandise protected the corporate’s aggressive benefit with the iPhone, together with iMessage, Apple’s Pockets app and the Apple Watch. How laborious do these perks actually make it to ditch your iPhone? Right here’s what I discovered.
Shedding iMessage
For essentially the most half, iPhone customers and Android customers can talk with one another simply by way of electronic mail, telephone calls and apps like Slack, however in terms of textual content messaging, there’s nonetheless an apparent break up often known as the “inexperienced bubble versus blue bubble” disparity.
When iPhone customers ship texts to different iPhones, the messages seem blue and might faucet into unique perks like an animation of birthday confetti. But when an iPhone consumer texts an Android consumer, the bubble turns inexperienced, many options break, and photographs and movies deteriorate in high quality.
Earlier than transferring my telephone quantity to the Pixel telephone, I used my iPhone to ship iMessages to my blue bubble comrades warning them that our conversations would quickly flip inexperienced. “Ew!” a buddy replied. However after many remarks made in jest, nobody protested, and I soldiered on.
Subsequent, I needed to detach my telephone quantity from iMessage on Apple’s web site to make sure that my textual content messages would cease going by way of Apple’s servers and arrive on my telephone. Except I did this, I’d not obtain texts from different iPhones. Finally, the conversations turned inexperienced. I ready myself for humiliation.
However nobody gave me a tough time or excluded me. I did discover, nonetheless, that many buddies had immediately stopped texting me photographs, maybe as a result of they knew the photographs would now not look nearly as good.
For years, a few of my closest buddies have texted me solely by way of Sign, the third-party messaging app with sturdy privateness protections and lots of the identical options as iMessage. Sign can also be accessible on Android, preserving that custom.
Apple has introduced that later this 12 months, it should enhance texts between iPhone and Android customers by adopting wealthy communication companies, a normal that Google and others built-in into their messaging apps years in the past. Texts despatched between iPhones and Androids will stay inexperienced, however photographs and movies can be greater high quality.
Shedding Apple Pockets
For iPhones, the go-to app for making cellular funds in shops is Apple Pockets, and for Android customers, the equal app is Google Pockets. The expertise of utilizing every pockets app was equivalent: I loaded up my bank cards and Clipper card for the Bay Space’s speedy transit service.
The Justice Division’s criticism of Apple Pockets facilities on how Apple offers solely its app entry to the iPhone’s cost chip, stopping competing pockets companies from utilizing that chip to make funds. However the best way Apple designed its Pockets app had no impression on my skill to modify to an Android.
Shedding the Apple Watch and different merchandise
For an iPhone proprietor, a important incentive to purchase extra Apple merchandise is that they work seamlessly collectively. A Mac laptop computer, for example, makes use of lots of the identical apps for messaging, word taking and reminders because the iPhone, and the information is synchronized among the many gadgets with Apple’s iCloud. In concept, the extra invested you might be in Apple’s ecosystem — and the extra that Apple restricts its merchandise from working with competing gadgets, the Justice Division says — the harder it’s to modify from an iPhone.
After I switched to an Android telephone, my emotions about utilizing different Apple merchandise ranged from reasonable annoyance to deep frustration:
-
The iPad labored independently from the iPhone, however I might now not see my textual content messages on the pill anymore. This was minor as a result of I don’t do a lot texting on my iPad.
-
My AirPods Professional had been OK — they linked rapidly with the Pixel for taking part in music. However the draw back is that the AirPods use Adaptive EQ, a know-how that tunes sound high quality to the form of your ear, and it really works solely with software program on the iPhone. So audio doesn’t sound nearly as good.
-
I couldn’t use my Android telephone to find my AirTags, the tiny Apple trackers I exploit to seek out my pockets and keys, on a map. However when my AirTags had been in my pocket, the Android telephone confirmed an alert that an “unknown tracker” was shifting round with me, a security function for combating stalkers.
-
The Apple Watch requires an iPhone to arrange, however its health monitoring can work independently. As a result of I had already arrange my watch, I might proceed to make use of it on the health club alongside my Android telephone. However I might now not see my detailed exercise information.
-
I bumped into different annoyances not particularly referred to as out within the lawsuit and eventually reached peak frustration once I tried to discover a alternative for Apple’s Notes, which I exploit usually on my Mac, iPad and telephone for work and private errands. I used options however didn’t like them, and mixed with the aforementioned points, it was all an excessive amount of.
The upshot: Switching is simple, till it’s not
My expertise isn’t common. Some individuals would care greater than others about how sure Apple merchandise would change in the event that they switched telephones. Youthful individuals would most likely care lots about missing iMessage in faculties, the place a inexperienced bubble has been identified to be an invite for mockery and exclusion, in accordance with schooling specialists. Mother and father who use AirTags to trace their youngsters would view dropping entry to these as a deal breaker.
The upshot from this experiment is that whereas it’s not technically laborious to modify to a unique telephone, there are many issues that would make you remorse it.
